BEYOND EMOTIONS

The above photo is of Bernie and me in our last days in Santa Barbara, California, before we made our way east to Massachusetts. A dear, dear friend who lived there sent it to me, and at first I had some trouble. “Who’s the woman next to him?” I wrote back. I actually thought it was her, only she’s much taller. She replied: “It’s you, darling. Who else would he look at like that?”

We were part of the Mesa Gang, as we called ourselves, neighbors who lived in the enclave once owned by the Beach Boys. Bernie and I lived in what was referred to as the Love House, because Mike Love had lived there. Before leaving, Bernie decided to throw a goodbye party, but not just any party, a clown party. We all had to dress up.

I put on the world’s frumpiest dress and hat with heavy clogs, Bernie—well, you can see Bernie. The others completely beat us to it, looking gorgeous, foolish, or bizarre, often all three together. Moshe YooWho Cohen joined us from San Francisco and, late in the evening, after food, drinks and laughter, gave a terrific show.

Several days later a convoy of trucks and cars left Santa Barbara in temperatures close to 100 Fahrenheit to roll cross-country to a new era in a cooler, more weather-diversified New England. We honked the horn, waved and shouted goodbyes to the best neighbors we’ve ever had, and on we went.

New beginnings for Bernie, and he, at the age of 64, with so much to look back on, diagnosed with Diabetes 2 and walking on hurting knees, always loved new beginnings (We always start from scratch was his business motto), so he lit a cigar while the dog Muji whined with excitement in the back seat. My own Golden, Woody, had died 10 days earlier, probably figuring that after Santa Barbara it was all going to go downhill anyway.

In some ways, Bernie continues to be an enigma for me. Isn’t that wonderful? You can know someone for 35 years and he’s still the koan that you’ve lived alongside and with, and when you return to it, it only gets deeper and deeper, even after he died, as we often feel towards Chinese and Japanese ancestors.

This part of the koan deals with how he related to people emotionally. I think that had Bernie gone to see a psychologist (which he never did, to my knowledge), the therapist would have concluded that the man sitting across from him/her was the most emotionally defended person s/he had ever seen. Day to day, he showed only a narrow gamut of emotions. He was usually genial, smiled and frowned moderately. He loved to laugh, but loved even more to make others laugh. Almost never got angry. His emotional register was narrow to moderate.

Only in very personal circumstances did both anger and laughter leave the gate and rush out. And he showed a wide range of feelings when he clowned, as you can see above. Otherwise, he was mostly an equanimous person, which is saying a lot given the many trials and tribulations that he faced over the years.

At the same time, people connected with him very, very deeply. I love the photo below, which I only saw after his stroke. It reminded me with a shock of the tremendous life force he emanated and the power of his listening. He reminded me from the get-go that my biggest job wasn’t to teach, but to listen.

Photo by Monika Winkelmann

I wondered about the connection that so many people reported having with him. He didn’t provide the usual emotional signals and body language that so many give. He didn’t nod in encouragement, eyes didn’t narrow or widen in response to what you were saying; he shook his head in sympathy only rarely.

We are so often told that expressing and listening to feelings is the cornerstone of good communication. We’re even told that it may be the cornerstone to our humanity, to how we relate to others and how we show our connection to others.

Zen training, in particular, didn’t give much place to emotions. They had their place in theory, but there was some kind of understanding that serious practitioners were always controlled and measured. I think some teachers were so uncomfortable with strong sensitivities and passions that they would recommend to the student that s/he see a therapist.

As Aussie might say: “Boring!”

I remember once doing the Myers-Briggs personality test along with other co-workers and practitioners, measuring our personality traits to see how we might fit into 16 different personality types. Only one among us scored high in Extraversion and Feeling. Her comment was: “That describes me well, and that’s exactly why I felt strange in Zen communities. I often felt that having such a personality was not truly acceptable, that real spiritual people were more interior, disciplined, and reserved. I wasn’t sure that I belonged.”

That took place 25 years ago, and I’d like to think that we can now accommodate a greater variety of personalities, not some Western variations on the Japanese stolid, restrained self. But I continue to marvel at the deep connection Bernie had with people—and not necessarily his students. I wonder at whether and how we may over-rate emotions and their role in connecting two different human beings.

Particularly in the United States, there’s a sense of: If you’re free with your emotions, well then, you’re free. You’re not inhibited or repressed; what you show is what there is, so you’re being honest and transparent. Emotional empathy is what powers all relationships, and if you don’t have it, relationships will suffer.

Yes, empathy is very important. But there are other energies at work between people that are harder to describe. When I watched Bernie, he projected an enormity that could take in everything. He knew how to listen, which helped you feel that you were fine just as you were. When it was time to talk—and he could talk a lot—it often came out of a deep silence that enclosed both words and no-words, a huge this-is-itness that made feelings feel small, even irrelevant. And, of course, he loved to interrupt those words with a small joke, a play-on-words, that served as reminders not to take things so seriously.

I think of that now, in a society that often studies a speaker’s every flicker of the eyes, every curve of the lips for hints to what she or he is really feeling. Some use emojis because they feel it’s imperative to show a feeling in response to anything that is said or written.

Why? Does it really enhance communication?

Bernie’s face was no emoji. It was never a matter of whether the corners of his lips turned up or down. At the moment when he responded, looking straight into your eyes, his face reflected a universe that had made room for you, as teensy as you were. There was no need for anything else.

                    Donate to My Blog                     Donate to Immigrant Families

You can also send a check to: Eve Marko, POB 174, Montague, MA 01351. Please write on the memo line whether this is in support or immigrant families or of my blog. Thank you.